« TV For America | Main | There Are More Things in Heaven and Earth... »

Edspresso's Kinky Links

August 25, 2006 04:32 PM

I stopped by for a cup of Edspresso yesterday and witnessed an attempted take-down of Delegate Eleanor Holmes Norton, the District of Columbia's nonvoting Congressional representative. It seems Edspresso couldn't follow her reasons for opposing vouchers. 

So I tried to follow Edspresso's reasoning, particularly in this section:

"Privately funded vouchers have existed in D.C. since 1993, so there has been more than enough time to detect any benefit from school choice programs in D.C.  And as it happens, this 2002 study which involves the D.C. choice program reports that African-American choice students produced better grades than their public school counterparts; their families were much more satisfied with their new schools; and the new educational environment was a vast improvement over what they had seen in public schools [emphasis added].

Really?  That's what the study showed?  Let's click and see.  Here's what I found in the study: 

"The most uncertain results for African Americans came from Washington, D.C.  As can be seen in Table 4, no significant differences were observed in year one, a large impact was observed after two years, but no impact was observed at the end of year three."

A blip in year two, no impact after three years, "uncertain results" -- that hardly makes a strong case for vouchers.  This is the second time I've clicked on an Edspresso link and found some monkey business.

Edspresso may leave behind a bad taste, but it does get your blood flowing and has a certain addictive quality.  Welcome to the blogroll.

Comments

You know times are tough for the privatization movement when edspresso can't even rely on a Paul Peterson study to support their pro-voucher "arguments!"

I guess that the Administration wants a lack of rigor in education study. That's probably why funding shifted from NSF which demanded well designed, peer reviewed work to the DOE which can be pushed around on the playground.
One might refer the readers to their favorite UCS member about the FDA's problems to hear the full rant complete with foam and spittle.
Evidently having the legislative, judicial, and executive branches isn't enough for some princes.
I suspect the old guard private school sector isn't pleased about having the "choice" folks riding on their coattails.

Categories

Accountability

AFT's Convention

Assessments

Charter

DC Schools

Early Childhood

Ed Tech

General

Higher Ed

Instruction

Labor

Legislation

Media

New Orleans

Paraprofessionals and School-Related Personnel

Privatization

School choice

School finance

School Improvement

Special Ed

Staff Quality

Standards

Teachers' Voices

Vouchers

Archives

March 2008

February 2008

January 2008

December 2007

November 2007

October 2007

September 2007

August 2007

July 2007

June 2007

May 2007

April 2007

March 2007

February 2007

January 2007

December 2006

November 2006

October 2006

September 2006

August 2006

July 2006

June 2006

May 2006

April 2006

March 2006

February 2006

January 2006

December 0000

Recent Posts

There's a Flag (or Several) on the Play

Your SES profits, sir

Edwizdom: "How long can you look at a test score?"

Clarification

What Would Chuckbutt Do?

The NCLBlog

Co-Editor: John
Co-Editor: Michele

Have a tip about NCLB? Contact our tipline at tips@letsgetitright.org.

For questions or general information, email us at info@letsgetitright.org.

Disclaimer: The NCLB Blog was established by the AFT as a forum where public education advocates, policymakers and others can exchange information and express their opinions on NCLB and related issues. The views expressed here are not the official views of the AFT or any of its affiliates. All claims otherwise would violate the spirit and purpose of the blog. © American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO. All rights reserved. Photographs and illustrations cannot be used without permission of the AFT.


Home About AFT Blog Sign Our Petition Contact Us Send to a Friend Printer-friendly Page

The NCLB Blog was established by the AFT as a forum where public education advocates, policymakers and others can exchange information and express their opinions on NCLB and related issues. The views expressed here are not the official views of the AFT or any of its affiliates. All claims otherwise would violate the spirit and purpose of the blog. © American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO. All rights reserved. Photographs and illustrations cannot be used without permission of the AFT.