Children = Test Scores? Slogan = What's Really Important?
September 26, 2007 03:44 PM
In a Newsday op-ed about NCLB reauthorization, Nancy Close offers serious recommendations for what it would take to achieve NCLB's goals.
Close, a health teacher in East Islip and president of the East Islip Teachers Association, writes:
To close the achievement gap and to ensure that, indeed, no child is left behind, Congress must recognize the importance of reducing class size; increase the training and retention of highly qualified teachers; expand access to early childhood education programs; and provide adequate funding for improved school facilities and materials.
She questions the way Congress is going about reauthorization:
While the dedicated teachers in my district embrace accountability and understand the value of fair tests that measure student progress, we are deeply concerned by the apparent rush to reauthorize NCLB. Speeding a revised NCLB through Congress could make a problematic law even worse. It's important that Congress listen to teachers and make sure that, this time, it gets the law right.
Reasonable enough, but Eduwonk doesn't like the lede, something about children not being test scores, and Eduwonk wonders about whether there's anyone who thinks children are test scores. Fair enough, but isn't the point of that phrase that the law places too much emphasis on test scores? And the wording isn't what's important, is it?
Let's keep our eyes on what really matters, which is, well, the subject of the op-ed: NCLB reauthorization. And it sounds to me as if she's on the right track.



Comments
We have done a good job making teachers, etc. accountable for their work. Now, how about the parents? If they want a healthy child, they are aware they must give the child good food, immunizations, etc. because the American Medical Association has been educating the public about their own responsibility for their own health. Have we, as teachers, been willing to educate the parents about ways THEY must help their child learn? Where is the voice of our unions telling the public that teachers are not able to do it ALL; we must have the parents doing THEIR part, too? The parent is the child's first, best teacher and has the obligation to oversee their student's education as well as their mental and physical health.
Posted by: kittiew | October 1, 2007 05:32 PM