« Give Us Growth Models...Or The Nation Will Explode | Main | George Archibald: From Ed-ucation Beat* to Ed-itor? »

And this is education reform?

October 31, 2007 12:53 PM

Last year, the Chicago Sun-Times reported on one of the effects of Renaissance 2010, an attempt to improve the quality of education in the city's schools.  Under Ren10, as it's sometimes called, the district closed certain high schools, sending students to nearby schools. 

From the Chicago Sun-Times, March 12, 2006 "School closings lead to surges in violence, fear on receiving end."

...Last semester, a Hyde Park Career Academy teacher was punched in the face after he asked a student for identification....

This is the kind of violence that is troubling Chicago's public high schools -- especially those accepting students from areas where failing schools are being systematically shut down under Mayor Daley's Renaissance 2010 initiative.

Since they began admitting those students in the fall of 2004, all eight schools have posted an increase in reported violence that is at least twice as high as the average for similar high schools systemwide, a Chicago Sun-Times analysis indicates.

The most dramatic example was Hyde Park, where the average number of reported violent incidents per month jumped 226 percent during that period, the analysis of CPS data showed.

In fact, Hyde Park was hit by a double-whammy, being forced to accept more than 300 students -- more students than any other receiving school -- in the past two years because two schools closed to freshmen: Englewood this school year and Calumet the year before....

Experts say spikes in violence can make students depressed, worried, anxious and, for the unlucky ones, victims....

In class, it's not unusual to hear new underclassmen swear at teachers, triggering arguments that interrupt instruction.

Most of the bathrooms have been shut down due to a rash of arson fires in them last year.

So, it should be pretty clear that this systemwide reform effort would hurt student achievement at Hyde Park Academy.  And it did, according to an article today's Chicago Sun-Times.  Here's the lede: "At Hyde Park Academy, a neighborhood high school serving black, mostly low-income students, reading scores have dropped dramatically over the last five years." 

Dropped. Dramatically.  But not surprisingly.

Comments

The Delaware study that was just released ("A More Accurate Growth Model", October 25, 2007), reported that current growth models made virtually no change to any school's AYP. See page 5:
2006 NC: 0.0% different
2006 TN: 2.0% different
2007 AK: 0.0% different
2007 DE: 4.1% different
2007 FL: 5.7% different

Given that the growth models did not seem to change many schools' AYP status and, even when it did, no one has validated that the change was a more accurate picture of reality: What exactly does a growth model do?

How will this help?

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Categories

Accountability

AFT's Convention

Assessments

Charter

DC Schools

Early Childhood

Ed Tech

General

Higher Ed

Instruction

Labor

Legislation

Media

New Orleans

Paraprofessionals and School-Related Personnel

Privatization

School choice

School finance

School Improvement

Special Ed

Staff Quality

Standards

Teachers' Voices

Vouchers

Archives

March 2008

February 2008

January 2008

December 2007

November 2007

October 2007

September 2007

August 2007

July 2007

June 2007

May 2007

April 2007

March 2007

February 2007

January 2007

December 2006

November 2006

October 2006

September 2006

August 2006

July 2006

June 2006

May 2006

April 2006

March 2006

February 2006

January 2006

December 0000

Recent Posts

There's a Flag (or Several) on the Play

Your SES profits, sir

Edwizdom: "How long can you look at a test score?"

Clarification

What Would Chuckbutt Do?

The NCLBlog

Co-Editor: John
Co-Editor: Michele

Have a tip about NCLB? Contact our tipline at tips@letsgetitright.org.

For questions or general information, email us at info@letsgetitright.org.

Disclaimer: The NCLB Blog was established by the AFT as a forum where public education advocates, policymakers and others can exchange information and express their opinions on NCLB and related issues. The views expressed here are not the official views of the AFT or any of its affiliates. All claims otherwise would violate the spirit and purpose of the blog. © American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO. All rights reserved. Photographs and illustrations cannot be used without permission of the AFT.


Home About AFT Blog Sign Our Petition Contact Us Send to a Friend Printer-friendly Page

The NCLB Blog was established by the AFT as a forum where public education advocates, policymakers and others can exchange information and express their opinions on NCLB and related issues. The views expressed here are not the official views of the AFT or any of its affiliates. All claims otherwise would violate the spirit and purpose of the blog. © American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO. All rights reserved. Photographs and illustrations cannot be used without permission of the AFT.